Official development blog for the PARANOIA roleplaying game. No description is available at your security clearance. The Computer is your friend.

Monday, March 24, 2008

The Lives of Others 

Though I always search for inspirational reference material for PARANOIA, I never expected to get a good lead from my mom. But she recently saw and loved the German film The Lives of Others (Das Leben der Anderen, 2006), directed by Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck (about as Germanic a name as I can imagine). The Lives of Others scored a remarkable 94% on Rotten Tomatoes. Having read the IMDB synopsis, now I'm all afire to see it. Thanks, Mom!

Set in (appropriately) 1984, The Lives of Others follows Gerd Weisler, a skilled and zealous captain in East Germany's feared secret police, the Stasi. Weisler begins spying on a playwright named Dreyman. Film critic Roger Ebert's perceptive review in the Chicago Sun-Times tells more:
Wiesler (Ulrich Muehe) first saw Dreyman at the opening of one of his plays, where he was informed by a colleague that Dreyman was a valuable man: 'One of our only writers who is read in the West and is loyal to our government.' How can that be? Wiesler wonders. Dreyman is good-looking, successful, with a beautiful lover; he must be getting away with something. Driven by suspicion, or perhaps by envy or simple curiosity, Wiesler has Dreyman's flat wired and begins an official eavesdropping inquiry.

He doesn't find a shred of evidence that Dreyman is disloyal. Not even in whispers. Not even in guarded allusions. Not even during pillow talk. The man obviously believes in the East German version of socialism, and the implication is that not even the Stasi can believe that. They are looking for dissent and subversion because, in a way, they think a man like Dreyman should be guilty of them. Perhaps they do not believe in East Germany themselves, but have simply chosen to play for the winning team. [...]

Driven by the specter of aggression from without, [East Germany] countered it with aggression from within, as sort of an anti-toxin. Fearing that its citizens were disloyal, it inspired them to be. True, its enemies were real. But the West never dropped the bomb, and East Germany and the other Soviet republics imploded after essentially bombing themselves.

Creepy real-world parallel: The late actor who played Gerd Weisler, Ulrich Muhe, was himself under Stasi surveillance during the Cold War, and later alleged his wife at that time, the actress Jenny Grollmann, was herself a registered Stasi informant. (Grollmann denied it.)
Posted by: Allen Varney / 12:05 AM

Comments:
Of course Grollmann denied it. They always deny it, sometimes even when confronted with the files. There's also a pretty standard list of excuses as to why they spied, when they eventually come around to admitting things. You'll want to read The File, by Timothy Garton Ash, which covers both his experience as a person of interest to the Stasi and more systematic reflections. You'll also want to read Stasiland by Anna Funder, which is a collection of stories with perspectives from all different sides.
# posted by Anonymous Doug : March 27, 2008 11:09 AM
 
Wow, you hadn't heard of this film until now?
# posted by Anonymous Adam-R-LON-1 : April 03, 2008 8:18 PM
 
Post a Comment

Copyright © 2004-8 by Greg Costikyan and Eric Goldberg. All your rights are belong to us. No bloody Creative Commons here! Bwahahaha!
No, seriously. If you make non-commercial use of stuff here, that's fine, but we reserve all commercial rights, and all rights to prepare derivative material on things posted here. In addition, posters of comments must be aware that we reserve the right to use whatever material they post here, and/or derivative works therefrom, in PARANOIA, supplementary products, licensed products, or derivative work, without any compensation whatever, for all time to come and throughout this universe and any alternate universes that may be discovered. At our discretion, and without obligation, we may, if it strikes our fancy, make a good faith effort to credit you for stuff we use, but we can't promise it won't slip our minds, in the hurly-burly of meeting deadlines. (Actually, we intend to do that, but it's possible we'll screw up.) By posting comments, you grant us a non-revocable, perpetual, non-exclusive license to use whatever you post, in whatsoever fashion we deem useful, here or in any other forum, in PARANOIA or in any and all future products, including but not limited to derivative works, and specifically but not exclusively including the microbrewery beer, ale and porter; salty and sugary snack; and tattoo design rights deriving therefrom. Woohoo! Is that enough legalese for you? The Computer is Your Friend.

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?