Games * Design * Art * Culture

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

"Understanding Games"

Via Kim Pallister via Raph comes a link to "Understanding Games," which attempts to do for games what Scott McCloud's Understanding Comics does for comics--that book explains comics in the form of a comic, while Understanding Games attempts to explain games in the form of a game (or series of connected games).

Excellent idea. The treatment is by my lights quite shallow, however; e.g., the first lesson is in terms of representation, and games are at their core systems... Representation is not irrelevant, but it doesn't get under the skin. Still, quite interesting.

Part 1
Part 2

posted by Greg at 6:09 PM 49 comments

49 Comments:

I'd like to see something called "Understanding Punk Games" that talks about when representation does get under the skin. Maybe I'll make it if I have time, maybe I'll make it using Santiago's framework.

By Patrick, at 9:59 PM

Shallow but fun. I might even suggest that rethinking about these issues this way is fun precisely because it's shallow. Forum based discussions and such tend to get bogged down in semantics, and creating semantics was never the point of trying to understand video games.

Personally, I've always tended to think more in terms of games as systems. When playing these games however I've let my mind wander into considering games rather abstractly: One might abandon rules all together and just think about what the player sees. Sort of a 'Turing test' for video games, if you like. After all, that's basically what rules and observations are when you get down to it.

Part 3 is up btw.

By Anonymous, at 1:00 AM

Understanding Comics is a masterpiece, precisely because it never steps out of the comics medium which it describes. While a noble attempt, Understanding Games is nothing more than a Powerpoint presentation with some interactivity tacked on. It is illustrative, but it doesn't work completely within the medium of games to do what it does.

One could argue that if I consider these nothing more than glorified powerpoint presentations, what of experiences like Halo/Gears of War, or Grim Fandango? Yeah, they're not games. All those multimedia/communications majors that invaded the industry along with the CDROM have pulled the wool over our eyes. Few modern examples of interactive software actually qualify as games by a strict definition, like Crawford's in Chris Crawford on Game Design (as opposed to his somewhat muddier definitions in his earlier work).

If the definition is looser, sure, these can be made to fit. I believe that they are shortchanging the medium by not getting across their ideas in the form of an interactive experience.

Then again, games simply might not be capable of doing so. Until we know one way or another, I think our future Scott McClouds should hold off. After all, Understanding Comics was created a century after craftpersons began seriously working in the medium, and a few decades after Eisner described the medium exhaustively in print.

Part 3 is out, and it tries teaching a concept through the interactive experience only.

By SteevR, at 12:57 PM

A cute primer. Would be great included in the curriculum of an elective 8th grade transdisciplinary class called Intro to Game Design.

By Rich, at 12:58 AM

very nice informations...thank you very much.mr solak not salak...

By evden eve nakliyat, at 4:42 PM

Habinfotech, we provide complete e-commerce solutions to integrate your sales transactions online.We engage specialized experts who have in-depth knowledge with corresponding technologies in offshore project implementation.
Our Web Development services include:
� Customized Application Development
� Web Development
� Database Integration
� Mobile Wireless Applications
� Content Management System (CMS) Solutions
� Ecommerce Shopping Carts
� Customer Relationship Management (CRM) Software
� Payment Gateway Integration
http://www.habinfotech.com

By fazayal, at 6:40 AM

liqingchao 07?09?03?
google??
google??
wow gold
wow gold
powerleveling
powerleveling
wow gold
wow gold
powerleveling
powerleveling
power leveling
power leveling
wow powerleveling
wow powerleveling
wow power leveling
wow power leveling
wow power level
wow power level
world of warcraft powerleveling
world of warcraft powerleveling
world of warcraft power leveling
world of warcraft power leveling
Crm
Crm
????
????
????
????
????
????
????
????
??????
??????
????
????
rolex replica
rolex replica
china tour
china tour
hongkong hotel
hongkong hotel
beijing tour
beijing tour

????
????
??
??
????
????
????
????
????
????
??
??
????
????
????
????
??????
??????
??????
??????
??????
??????
???
??
??
??
?????
?????
??????
??????

??????
??????
???
???
?????
?????
??????
??????
google??
????
????
????
????
???
??
??
????
????
?????
?????

By Anonymous, at 2:29 AM

maple story
maple story mesos
maple story cheats
maple story meso
maple story hacks
maple story items
maple story guides
cheap maple story
buy maple story mesos

rf online
rf online cp
rf online currency
rf online dalant
rf online disena
buy rf online currency
buy rf online cp
buy rf online dalant

By Anonymous, at 3:40 AM

By Anonymous, at 8:53 AM

Nice
!
Thank
you
for
your
info.

By Anonymous, at 11:47 AM

??
????
????
????
????
?????
????
??
??
????
????
????
????
????
???
???
????
????

By Anonymous, at 9:56 PM

wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
cheap wow gold
world of warcraft gold
Buy WoW gold
World of Warcraft Gold
Buy World of Warcraft gold
Cheap World of Warcraft Gold
buy Cheap World of Warcraft Gold
wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
cheap wow gold
world of warcraft gold
Buy WoW gold
World of Warcraft Gold
Buy World of Warcraft gold
Cheap World of Warcraft Gold
buy Cheap World of Warcraft Gold

By Anonymous, at 10:34 PM

??????|??????|??????
??????|??????|??????
??????|??????|??????
??????|??????|??????
??????|??????|??????
??????|??????|??????
??????|??????|??????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????
????|????|????

By Anonymous, at 2:43 AM

Viagra is a drug that is prescribed for a very fragile disease like erectile dysfunction. Hence people prefer to go for this drug after going through the viagra info sites. In these sites people get all the information required and related to the drug.

By viagra, at 4:49 AM

EVE ISK
EQ2 Gold
FFXI Gil
Guild Wars Gold
Lineage 2 Adena
Runescape Money
wow power leveling
wow gold
cheap wow gold
World of Warcraft Gold
wow power leveling
EVE ISK
EQ2 Gold
EQ2 plat
everquest 2 gold
FFXI Gil
FFXI Gil
FFXI Gil
Guild Wars Gold
Lineage 2 Adena
Maple Story Mesos
cheap Mesos
Runescape Money
Runescape Gold
runescape items
SilkRoad Gold
wow gold
warcraft gold
cheap wow gold
wow gold
warcraft gold
LOTRO Gold
wow power leveling
cheap wow gold
wow gold
cheap wow gold

runescape gold
runescape money
runescape items
cheap runescape money
cheap runescape gold
wow power leveling
wow powerleveling
world of warcraft power leveling
wow power leveling
wow powerleveling
world of warcraft power leveling
wow power leveling
wow powerleveling
world of warcraft power leveling
wow power leveling
wow powerleveling
world of warcraft power leveling
ffxi gil

Final Fantasy XI Gil
ro Zeny
wow gold
cheap wow gold
cheap wow gold
eq2 gold
eq2 plat
everquest 2 gold
lotro gold
lotro power leveling
lotro power leveling
lotro powerleveling
swg credits
swg credits